Bethlehem Village Store offers a delightful, rustic menu that perfectly captures the essence of comfort food with a local twist. The star of their breakfast offerings is undoubtedly the Buttermilk Pancakes, served fluffy and golden, with a side of fresh, local maple syrup that adds a rich sweetness to every bite. For something heartier, the Country Sausage Biscuits and Gravy is a favorite, featuring savory sausage nestled atop warm biscuits, smothered in creamy gravy—a true taste of traditional New England.
Lunch options don’t disappoint either. Their Homemade Meatloaf Sandwich is a satisfying choice, with thick slices of tender meatloaf, freshly baked bread, and a tangy tomato glaze that perfectly balances the savory flavors. The Turkey Club is another standout, with layers of juicy turkey, crisp bacon, and fresh veggies, all tucked into a soft roll that makes every bite a comforting delight.
Dinner time brings a variety of options for every palate, with the Grilled Salmon being a top pick for those craving a lighter, yet flavorful dish. The salmon is perfectly seared, seasoned with herbs, and served with a side of roasted vegetables that complement the fish beautifully. For those in the mood for something richer, the Prime Rib is a must-try—cooked to perfection, tender, and served with a side of mashed potatoes and a rich au jus.
No meal at Bethlehem Village Store would be complete without a slice of their famous Apple Pie for dessert. Made with locally sourced apples, the pie boasts a buttery crust and just the right amount of sweetness, making it the perfect end to a truly satisfying meal.